Wednesday, September 28, 2016

Twitter Users: Let's Convert Twitter to Cooperative Ownership

Let's us, Twitter users, turn it into a cooperative. 

WHAT? You don’t have $16 billion in your savings account? Neither do any of the other potential purchasers. Keep reading.

Here’s how it works:

PURCHASE

Less than 1% of Twitter users (3 million) buy 100 shares each at the current price (assume this morning's price of $23 per share. Cost of 100 shares = $2,300). (Among this 1% will be users who already own shares, like the coop idea and are willing to pledge those shares for cooperative ownership).

If 1% of all Twitter users purchase (or pledge) 100 shares or more, that would represent about 40% of all shares. These insiders then vote to convert to cooperative ownership.

The $16 billion price tag would be financed by
1) a one-time membership fee of $25 paid by 60% of current users (the other 40% of current users fall away). This generates $4.5 billion.
2) a loan for the rest: $11.5 billion. I've assumed a 10 year fully amortizing loan at 4% in quarterly payments.

The users who buy in now are basically lending the money to make this happen. They would get paid the agreed purchase price when the deal closes and, hopefully, that would be the same price that they pay for the shares now.

ANNUAL OPERATIONS

The members of the new Twitter cooperative would each pay the $25 one-time membership fee, PLUS an annual assessment of about $9.80 per member. 

The annual fee would cover the $400+ million annual deficit that Twitter has been running ($450 million in 2015 and about $410 million for the past 4 quarters) PLUS the amortization of the loan. With the loan repaid after the first 10 years, the annual assessment would go down to less than $2.50 per year (assuming no inflation and no reduction of the deficit).

Critical assumptions:
- Share price: one analyst predicts the share price will fall to $17 (vs today's $23+)
- Number of users who will agree to be members of the cooperative. I changed the assumption to 50% of current users. This increases the loan amount and reduces the users to divvy up the annual obligation increasing the annual assessment to $12.40 per member.


I’m looking forward to your comments. My numbers are based on a spreadsheet that I'm happy to send to subscribers of my blog.

LET'S DO THIS!

5 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We set up a group at loomio.org: Buy Twitter. Join us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Since posting this, TWTR has been hovering in the $17-18 range.

    My model assumed an annual subscription fee to co-op members to pay off the existing shareholders. I've dropped this. Now going with co-op members purchasing shares in the co-op at $150 per share. We will have more information on Monday, October 17.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!. cooperative learning

    ReplyDelete